Was it just last year that I read Marilynn Robinson's acclaimed Gilead
Home
So unveils Home. It's not a novel that sets alight the reader's stage with action. Rather, the action is in small gestures. The touch of a hand. A ring of laughter. A shared memory. Gentle teasing as Jack and Glory get to know each other after 20 years. And their father to watch them over. They tried hard to please him, knowing as Jack does that his presence itself is an ache to his father, a reminder of a past that best remains to be forgotten. Jack is the eternal tortured soul - the fallen man. Is there redemption for him? In the beginning, I sympathized with him, but towards the end I was frustrated with him. Jack remained a mystery, the motive for his actions inscrutable to me.
Towards the end, Glory describes Jack as "a man of sorrows and acquainted with grief, and as one from whom men hide their face." Somehow, that seems so cruel. Almost excruciatingly sad. But that's how the novel is. An overwhelming work of despair. But not despair that humiliates. But despair that humbles. And in the end, strangely exalts. Perdition may just be life, after all. I can't say I understood all of the novel, maybe I read it too fast. But there is plenty to think about. And oh well, like Glory would have said, "Ah, Jack, you make me sad."
Verdict: Not quite in the same class as Gilead. But a sadder book. Oh! Such a sad book.
Rating : 3.5/5

Nice review - It is interesting to read the different responses that Marilynne Robinson provokes. I was not all that keen on her homely characters and I found Jack by far the most interesting person in the book.
ReplyDeleteI reviewed it myself - you can find it on my title index if you're interested!
Nice review! I loved your comment "Perdition may just be life, after all" - though reading it makes me sad.
ReplyDelete